• News
  • Guides
  • Reviews
  • Media
  • About
  • News
  • Guides
  • Reviews
  • Media
  • About
Sign up Now (For Free)

Sign up for our newsletter and receive the latest automotive news in your inbox!

Invalid email address
We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Thanks for subscribing!
News
Read Now
  • All News
  • Automakers
  • Automobiles
  • Auto Shows
  • Business
  • EVs & Environment
  • Guides
  • Lawsuits/Legal
  • Regulatory
  • Ride-Sharing
  • Safety & Recalls
  • Technology
Recent
  • The Rearview Mirror: The Car That Started a ’70s Car Design Craze
  • Inflation Reduction Act Paying Off as Battery Makers Invest Billions in U.S. Factories
  • Back in Production, Ford Again Raises Pricing for F-150 Lightning.
  • First Look: 2024 Hyundai Sonata
  • Despite Two Decades of Warnings, Distracted Driving Remains a Major Problem
  • Treasury Dept Ruling Expected to Cut EV Tax Credits
  • Sen. Manchin Threatening to Sue Over New EV Battery Rules
  • Ford Bolsters EV Supply Chain with $4.5B Nickel Processing Plant
  • Unified UAW Talks Tough Before Contract Talks with Detroit Three
  • Faraday Future May Have One: Production Begins
Editor’s Choice
    Reviews
    Read Now
    • All Reviews
      • Feeder
    • Classic Cars
    • Concept Cars
    • Convertibles
    • Coupes
    • Crossovers/CUVs
    • Diesel
    • Hot hatches
    • Hybrids
    • Luxury Vehicles
    • Minivans
    • Muscle Cars
    • Pickups
    • Sedans
    • Sports Cars
    • Super Cars
    • SUVs
    Recent Reviews
    • A Week With: 2023 Nissan Rogue Platinum AWD
    • A Week With: 2023 Kia Soul GT-Line
    • A Week With: 2023 Ford Maverick Tremor
    • A Week With: 2023 Volkswagen ID.4 AWD Pro S
    • A Week With: 2023 Infiniti QX80
    • A Week With: 2023 Genesis GV80 Prestige 3.5 Turbo
    • First Drive: 2024 Dodge Hornet R/T
    • First Drive: 2023 Dodge Hornet GT
    • First Drive: 2023 Genesis Electrified GV70
    • First Drive: 2023 Nissan Ariya e-4orce AWD
    Editor’s Choice
      Guides
      Car Warranty
      • Endurance Warranty Reviews
      • BMW Extended Warranty
      • Extended Warranty For Cars Over 100k Miles
      • Extended Car Warranty Cost
      • Subaru Extended Warranty
      • CarShield Reviews
      • CarShield Cost
      • Aftermarket Car Warranty
      • CARCHEX Warranty Reviews
      • Reputable Extended Car Warranty Companies
      • Used Car Warranty Companies
      • Best Car Warranty
      • Is CarShield A Scam?
      • Mercedes Extended Warranty
      • CarShield Plans
      Insurance
      • How To Identify A Car Insurance Company
      • Geico Mechanical Breakdown Insurance
      • How Far Back Does A Car Insurance Company Look
      • Mechanical Breakdown Insurance For Used Cars
      • State Farm Mechanical Breakdown Insurance
      • Mechanical Breakdown Insurance From Progressive
      • Dollar A Day Insurance
      • Auto Insurance For SSI Recipients
      • Car Insurance Rates After A Suspended License
      • Auto Insurance For Salvage Vehicles
      • Average Cost of Dodge Ram 1500 Car Insurance
      • Car Insurance Florida
      • Full Coverage Auto Insurance
      • GrubHub Insurance
      • Amazon Delivery Auto Insurance
      Shipping
      • Car Shipping Companies
      • uShip Reviews
      • Auto Shipping From California To Hawaii
      • Montway Auto Transport Reviews
      • Cheap Car Shipping
      • Easy Auto Ship Reviews
      • Auto Shipping Miami
      • Auto Shipping To Alaska
      • Car Shipping Cost
      • Auto Shipping Hawaii
      • Auto Shipping Puerto Rico
      • Sherpa Auto Transport Reviews
      • Auto Shipping Atlanta
      • Auto Shipping Boston
      • Auto Shipping. Chicago
      About
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Terms of Use
      • Privacy Policy
      • Affiliate Disclosure
      • Sitemap
      TheDetroitBureau.com

      More than just “another” place to find news, reviews, spy shots, commentary, features, and guides about the auto industry. TheDetroitBureau doesn’t stop with the press releases or confuse a few lines of opinion with insightful, in-depth reporting.

      Contact Us

      Like what you see? Have some ideas for making The Detroit Bureau.com even better? Let us know, we’d love to hear your voice.

        Media
        Listen Now
        • Headlight News: All Episodes
        More from TheDetroitBureau
        • Guides
        • Latest News
        • Auto Reviews
        • Podcasts
        Headlight News

        TheDetroitBureau.com’s Headlight News offers a look at the past week’s top automotive news stories, as well as what’s coming up in the week ahead. Check out the week’s top story and our latest review…along with a dive into the past with this week in automotive history.

        home > reviews > SEC Says Musk’s Response to Lawsuit “Borders on the Ridiculous”

        SEC Says Musk’s Response to Lawsuit “Borders on the Ridiculous”

        Regulators tell court Tesla CEO failed to clear a single tweet with automaker per settlement.

        Paul A. Eisenstein
        Paul A. Eisenstein , Publisher & Editor-in-Chief
        March 19, 2019
        Tesla CEO Elon Musk shown during last week's unveiling of the new Model Y.

        Federal regulators have shot back at Tesla CEO Elon Musk in their battle over a contempt-of-court lawsuit, claiming the 47-year-old executive’s legal argument “borders on the ridiculous.”

        The case stems from a tweet Musk filed last month declaring that Tesla would produce 500,000 vehicles this year. The Securities and Exchange Commission considered that “material” guidance which, under terms of a separate case last year, required the CEO to first get the approval of the company. But, the SEC said in a new filing, Musk has not cleared a single tweet with Tesla as he had agreed to.

        Breaking News!

        The lawsuit is being heard by U.S. Judge Alison Nathan who could hold Musk in contempt and levy fine or other forms of punishment. The Tesla executive was already forced to relinquish his post as chairman and could now be removed as the automaker’s chief executive officer.

        (SEC sues VW and former CEO, alleging “massive fraud.” Click Here for the story.)

        The latest run-in between the SEC and Musk stems from a case the agency brought against Tesla and its CEO last summer resulting from the South African-born executive’s claim that he was going to take the automaker private at $420 a share, relying on funding from a Saudi Arabian sovereign investment fund. That initially sent Tesla shares soaring, though they tanked after it became clear that no real deal with the fund was in place.

        Tesla and Musk subsequently paid $20 million each in fines and Musk was removed as chairman. A frequent user of social media, he also agreed that anything potentially relevant to Tesla’s business and its stock price would first be cleared with the company’s “disclosure counsel.”

        The SEC claims that wasn’t the case with the February 19 tweet which said, “Tesla made 0 cars in 2011, but will make around 500k in 2019.” It says the tweet was in contempt of last year’s settlement.

        (Click Here to check out the new Tesla Model Y.)

        For their part, Musk’s attorneys levelled a two-pronged response to the government’s allegations. For one thing, they argued, the information in the tweet had already been made public.

        In fact, it differs from earlier comments made in both a government filing and during a January earnings call with analysts and reporters.

        In the regulatory filing, Tesla said, “We are targeting annualized Model 3 output in excess of 500,000 units sometime between Q4 of 2019 and Q2 of 2020.” Musk also told analysts on reporters participating in the earnings call that with a new Shanghai plant coming on line later this year, Tesla could get “very close” to an overall production rate of 10,000 vehicles a week “by the end of the year.” Both statements would suggest that overall production for the year would not approach 500,000, something that could be seen as being updated by Musk’s February 19th tweet.

        Musk explains the four Model Y variants.

        The CEO’s attorneys also fired back at the SEC last week by declaring the agency is attempting to limit Musk’s rights to free speech.

        “As the SEC interprets and seeks to enforce it, the Order’s injunction is a de facto gag on a broad spectrum of statements implicating Tesla,” the lawyers wrote in their court filing, accusing the agency of an “unconstitutional power grab.”

        With the permission of the Manhattan-based federal judge, the agency has now responded that Musk agreed to prior approval as part of last year’s settlement, adding that, “As long as a statement submitted for pre-approval is not false or misleading, Tesla would presumably approve its publication without prior restraint on Musk.”

        Legal experts say Judge Nathan is not expected to issue a harsh penalty against Musk but could use the latest case – should she agree with the SEC – to strictly hold the executive to the terms of his earlier agreement.

        (Tesla reverses position – will keep some stores open. Click Here for the latest.)

        But she may also focus on a series of comments Musk has made in recent months. The executive, who also runs the rocket launching company SpaceX, has never been shy when it comes to taking on the SEC, however, an agency he has belittled as the “Shortseller Enrichment Commission,” a reference to the investors who have bet against the company’s success.

        During a December interview on the TV newsmagazine “60 Minutes,” Musk declared, “I want to be clear. I do not respect the SEC. I do not respect them.”

        That comment might have been ignored but for the fact that Musk also confirmed that his Twitter posts were not being screened by Tesla. Asked if that could cause problems, he added, “Well, I guess we might make some mistakes. Who knows?”

        That’s one of the things that the SEC hopes to address with its compliance order. Tesla has already set up a disclosure controls committee that includes three of its board members, Brad Buss, Antonio Gracias and James Murdoch. The policy is supposed to apply to all senior executives under last year’s settlement.

        How to Care for Your Car

        Cheap Car Warranty

        Editor's Choice

        Best Extended Car Warranty

        Editor's Choice
        Recently Published

        A Week With: 2022 Toyota Corolla Hatchback XSE

        Dec. 27, 2022
        Genesis X concept best

        Genesis X Concept Could Win Back Coupe Buyers

        March 31, 2021
        Z Proto with Uchida

        First Look: New Nissan Z Proto

        Sept. 15, 2020

        2 responses to “SEC Says Musk’s Response to Lawsuit “Borders on the Ridiculous””

        1. John says:
          March 19, 2019 at 1:52 pm

          Elon should line up financing to go private and tell the SEC to F– off.

          Reply
        2. Allen says:
          March 23, 2019 at 1:19 am

          Almost everything Elon says borders on the ridiculous. As far as free speech goes, I would think that refers to an individuals right to state their own personal thoughts/opinions. I question that is allows one to state what he has personally decided the (publicly held) company is going to do, or what he has decided the opinion of the board of the company is. I would hope that a CEO would be more of a leader and team player, encouraging the rest of the people who run the company to participate. “We” and “I” do not necessarily communicate the same impression.

          Reply

        Leave a Reply Cancel reply

        Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

        What Are You Looking For?

        See More
        Buying a new car? See our recommended reviews and guides.
        Buying a new car? See our recommended reviews and guides.
        Reviews and Resources When You Are Looking For a New Car
        Collection
        Car Reviews and Guides
        Collection

        Car Reviews and Guides
        Recommends
        The Best Car Insurance Companies in 2022 (with Costs)
        Recommends

        The Best Car Insurance Companies in 2022 (with Costs)
        Recommends
        Best Car Warranties – 2021 Comparison (Factory & Extended)
        Recommends

        Best Car Warranties – 2021 Comparison (Factory & Extended)
        Receommends
        Cheap Car Shipping
        Receommends

        Cheap Car Shipping
        Close
        Reviews and Resources When You Are Looking For a New Car
        Collection
        Car Reviews and Guides
        Collection

        Car Reviews and Guides
        Recommends
        The Best Car Insurance Companies in 2022 (with Costs)
        Recommends

        The Best Car Insurance Companies in 2022 (with Costs)
        Recommends
        Best Car Warranties – 2021 Comparison (Factory & Extended)
        Recommends

        Best Car Warranties – 2021 Comparison (Factory & Extended)
        Receommends
        Cheap Car Shipping
        Receommends

        Cheap Car Shipping
        Close
        Share this article:
        © The Detroit Bureau 2023
        • Guides
        • Privacy Policy
        • Terms of Use
        • Affiliate Disclosure
        • Contact Us
        • Sitemap
        Follow Us: